Stricter penalties when same level of care is not provided to a child born alive after an abortion?

This bill has Passed the House of Representatives
Bill Summary

The bill mandates that healthcare practitioners must provide the same level of care to a child born alive after an abortion as they would for any child born at the same gestational age. The child must be immediately admitted to a hospital. Practitioners and employees who fail to provide or report this care face fines, imprisonment (up to five years), or both. Those who intentionally kill or attempt to kill a child born alive can be prosecuted for murder. Mothers are exempt from prosecution and can file civil lawsuits against non-compliant practitioners or employees. Sponsor: Rep. Ann Wagner (Republican, Missouri, District 2)
View full bill text ➔

How do you feel?

You can still save your opinion to your scorecard, but since the vote has already taken place, your opinion won't be sent to your lawmakers.

Opponents say

•      "This reckless bill would impede families from making significant quality-of-life decisions, such as being able to provide comfort or spiritual care in tragic and painful situations. Abortions later in pregnancy are the result of complex decisions, and patients make these health care decisions thoughtfully, carefully, and painstakingly. These incredibly difficult medical decisions should be made by patients in consultation with their physicians and without any external interferences. Instead, this bill takes decision making out of the hands of families in crisis and limits the freedom of our patients to make the decisions that are right for them. Laws that ban or criminalize evidence-based care and rely on medically unsupported theories and misinformation are dangerous to families and their clinicians. This bill negatively affects all obstetric and gynecologic care." Source: A statement from Iffath Abbasi Hoskins, MD, FACOG, president of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists


•      "Opponents, noting the rarity of such births and citing laws already making it a crime to kill newborn babies, said the bill was unnecessary. They said it is part of a push by abortion opponents to curb access to the procedure and intimidate doctors who perform it, and said late-term abortions generally occur when the infant is considered incapable of surviving after birth. Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., a leading Democrat on health issues, said the measure would force women to accept ‘care that may directly conflict with your wishes at a deeply personal, often incredibly painful moment in your life -— because politicians in Washington decided their beliefs mattered more than yours.’" Source: PBS Newshour Article on the opinions of the act when brought to Congress in 2019

Proponents say

•      "I am proud that one of the first things the 119th Congress did was prioritize consideration of my legislation to protect the lives of innocent children.  It’s about to be a new day in Washington with a Presidential Administration who will make it their mission to restore respect for the dignity of all life. Newborn infants, who are among the most vulnerable Americans, need us to defend their lives and safety, and we in Congress will be strong partners in providing essential protections for infants who cannot fight for themselves. This cannot and should not be a complicated issue. Every child deserves a chance to live and thrive. If babies survive an abortion, doctors must treat them like they would any other patient and provide lifesaving medical care to make sure they can grow up to have fulfilling lives like any other. It’s time innocent children are treated like the blessings they are." Source: The Sponsor of this act Rep. Ann Wagner (Republican, Missouri, District 2), via a press release


•     "On behalf of the over 2.5 million members of the Faith & Freedom Coalition, I applaud Rep. Ann Wagner for reintroducing the Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act. This commonsense bill would simply require that a child born alive after an attempted abortion receive appropriate medical treatment and be transferred to a hospital—the same as would be done for any other human being at the same level of development. It is truly a reasonable and ethical approach to how we, as a nation, should expect that any innocent human beings would be treated in a medical setting." Source: Timothy R. Head, Executive Director, Faith & Freedom Coalition