Should funding be withheld from sanctuary cities?
The bill withholds certain federal grants from jurisdictions that violate federal law by prohibiting their officers from communicating with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). In addition, it protects jurisdictions that comply with detainers from being sued, while allowing victims of crime to sue jurisdictions that refuse to comply and subsequently release criminal aliens onto the streets. It also clarifies ICE’s statutory probable cause standards to issue detainers for the first time: ensures unlawful immigrants convicted of drunk driving or arrested for other dangerous crimes are detained during their removal proceedings. Sponsor: Rep. Bob Goodlatte [R-VA-6]
View full bill text ➔
How do you feel?
Opponents say
• Houston Police Chief Art Acevedo argues: "The perception we’re going to create by having this legislation is going to have a tremendously chilling effect on the immigrant community. What this legislation does is say to me and my team that we don’t have the authority to keep our [officers] focused on criminals. If all the sudden I have a police officer who decides 'I’m going to go play ICE agent all day and harass day laborers at Home Depot,' explain to me, when I lose my authority to tell my officers they can’t do that, how does that enhance public safety?
Proponents say
• Dale Wilcox, general counsel and executive director for Immigration Reform Law Institute, believes “For Congressman Goodlatte to give police protection from lawsuits, we think is hugely important. Anti-borders lawyers are flooded with money from people [that] routinely sue police departments for ‘violating’ the supposed constitutional rights of illegal aliens. Many of the sheriffs we speak to are constantly worried about these suits due to their budget constraints and the general lack of support they receive from their state and from the federal government.”