Exclude real estate agents from the definition of “employee?”
H.R. 3495 is a bipartisan bill that would amend the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) to exclude direct sellers and qualified real estate agents from the definition of an employee. This bill would align federal labor law with existing tax law, classifying these workers as independent contractors rather than employees for purposes of the FLSA. As a result, they would no longer be covered by the FLSA’s minimum wage and overtime protections.
Sponsor: Rep. Kevin Kiley (Republican, California, District 3)
View full bill text ➔
How do you feel?
Opponents say
• "By categorically excluding direct sellers and real estate agents from employment law, this bill would imperil the independence of those workers by enabling brokers and suppliers to freely exercise control over all aspects of their day-to-day work. Additionally, it does seem possible that other workers – such as those at call centers – might be inadvertently swept up by this legislation and lose their rights to decent pay and safe working conditions. This bill weakens labor protections for workers in these sectors and invites serious unintended consequences." Source: Rep. Robert C. “Bobby” Scott (Democrat, Virginia, District 3)
• "Employee status under the FLSA is defined more broadly than in perhaps any other federal statute, to effectuate its remedial purposes. It is also interpreted by courts in a nuanced, rigorous and fact-sensitive manner using the economic realities test. H.R. 3495 would do away with these sensible approaches to employee status for direct sellers and qualified real estate agents, in favor of an over-simplistic contract-driven analysis. This approach would poorly serve such workers, result in their misclassification as independent contractors, and open the floodgates to further tax classification-based determinations of employee status in other industries. Adopting such an approach here would be particularly unwise given the evidence of widespread misclassification in many industries, leading to millions of workers losing the wages and benefits to which they are entitled." Source: Karen Maoki, Interim Executive Director for the National Employment Lawyers Association
Proponents say
• "For decades, the tax code has recognized direct sellers and real estate agents as independent contractors. These workers deserve our support to thrive, not more bureaucratic uncertainty. Clarifying our labor laws will support hard work and innovation while providing workers with the flexibility they so clearly need." Source: Rep. Kevin Kiley (Republican, California, District 3), Sponsor of H.R. 3495
• "This legislation is essential to providing clarity under federal labor law and protecting the independent contractor status that allows real estate professionals to build their businesses and serve consumers. We are grateful to Congressman Kevin Kiley for leading this effort and look forward to working with him and the committee to ensure this important bill continues to move forward." Source: Heather Ozur, President of the California Association of REALTORS®
• "Just like we have in previous Congresses, NAR strongly supports this common sense, bipartisan bill, which is designed to clarify the Fair Labor Standards Act and ensure that real estate professionals are treated fairly and consistently under federal law. 89% of NAR members are currently classified as independent contractors, and the real estate market contributes nearly 20% to our country’s GDP. Independent contractors are a vital part of the real estate economy, and this legislation affirms their role while reducing unnecessary confusion and regulatory burdens." Source: Shannon McGahn, Executive Vice President and Chief Advocacy Officer for the National Association of REALTORS®
