$45 billion for affordable housing and homelessness prevention programs?
The Housing for All Act authorizes $45 billion annually towards the federal Housing Trust Fund, and funds for Housing and Urban Development (HUD) programs that provide housing, such as section 202 and section 811 programs. The bill also establishes crisis intervention teams to provide healthcare support for urgent needs. It includes a “safe parking” initiative to help those living in vehicles and further provides protections against race and gender discrimination. Sponsor: Rep. Ted Lieu (Democrat, California, District 36)
View full bill text ➔
How do you feel?
Opponents say
• "In order to reduce homelessness, policymakers at all levels must understand that chronic and long-term homelessness is not primarily a housing problem—it is a human problem. According to a 2019 report from the University of California Los Angeles analyzing data from 64,000 surveys, 75 percent of the unsheltered homeless have substance-abuse disorders, 78 percent have mental health disorders, and 84 percent have physical health conditions. In other words, these are not simply people who lack shelter; the majority are suffering from profound human pathologies. As homelessness threatens to become an entrenched problem in American cities, it is more important than ever for policymakers to have a clear understanding of the failures of current policy, as well as the potential for reform. In re-orienting the public response toward better outcomes, policymakers must begin with a simple premise: Any effort to reduce homelessness must address addiction, mental illness, and social pathologies—not just physical housing, lack of which is frequently a reflection of deeper problems." Source: Christopher Rufo, The Heritage Foundation
• "I worry that what Housing First has done is taken a lot of people who are very much struggling and very much deserving of our compassion, though I think how we provide that compassion is up for debate,” he said, “but it also introduces people with serious drug problems, with serious mental illness problems, into communities with kids who are already in a very unstable situation. And now they’re having things like drug use normalized around them." Source: Former Senator J.D. Vance (Republican, Ohio), National Housing Conference
• "The year-over-year increases in homelessness funding and in the number of people experiencing homelessness demonstrate the significant incompetence of HUD and the Continuum of Care Program…Now, communities are struggling with not knowing where public money meant to reduce homelessness goes and what it accomplishes. They struggle with increased drug use, untreated mental illness, crime, and destitution–particularly around homeless shelters and housing. Innovative programs that seek to address homelessness through requirements and performance measures are shut out of funding…Without reforms, more communities will see continued increases in human misery while non-performing governments and nonprofits get fat on millions of dollars in federal funding." Source: Paul Webster, Cicero Institute
Proponents say
• "As housing cost and homelessness continue to rise for older adults, it is time for the bold steps laid out in the Housing for All Act. The bill is a much-needed response to the longstanding underinvestment in critical housing resources, which has left our country with a woefully insufficient supply of affordable housing for older adults…For example, the bill’s $2.5 billion investment in HUD’s Section 202 Supportive Housing for the Elderly program would mean tens of thousands of new homes, as well as new Service Coordinators to help older adult residents age in community. LeadingAge applauds Senator Padilla on the reintroduction of this legislation, and we look forward to doing all we can to secure its enactment." Source: Katie Smith Sloan, President & CEO of LeadingAge
• "Housing is a basic human right, not a privilege…The lack of affordable housing hurts Americans nationwide and disproportionately affects low-income communities and communities of color. Officials across California know that we have the tools to end homelessness and lower the cost of housing for Americans, but we need significant federal investments to scale up creative and effective housing solutions. I am reintroducing the Housing for All Act to finally treat the homelessness and affordable housing crises with the seriousness they deserve — and I won’t stop this fight until every person has a place to call home.”" Source: Senator Alex Padilla (Democrat, California)
• "When I served alongside Senator Padilla and Congressman Lieu, I was proud to support the ‘Housing for All Act,’ which would provide desperately needed federal resources to develop more affordable housing and reduce homelessness. This bill invests in federal programs that have a proven track record of saving lives and support local strategies like the City’s Inside Safe initiative that are working to get Angelenos off the streets, into interim housing, and ultimately, into permanent housing. Thank you Senator Padilla and Congressman Lieu for your leadership on this lifesaving bill." Source: Karen Bass, Mayor of Los Angeles
