Loosen restrictions on vehicular pursuits in D.C.?
H.R. 5143 would remove the conditions that prohibit the engagement in vehicular pursuits in D.C., such as the suspect posing an immediate threat to others or being suspected of committing a violent crime. Instead, officers would be restricted from engaging in pursuit only if the pursuit would pose a risk of harm to the officer, public, or property, or if a high-ranking officer reasonably deems that it would be futile or that the suspect could be apprehended in a more effective means.
Sponsor: Rep. Clay Higgins (Republican, Louisiana, District 3)
View full bill text ➔
How do you feel?
Opponents say
• "In the place of proven strategies aimed at reducing and preventing crime, President Trump’s decision to commandeer the police and fill the streets with National Guard servicemembers – who are not trained to act as police officers–is not simply a matter of political theater and distraction. It also poses a dire threat to longstanding efforts to foster trust between the police and the communities they serve, especially in light of President Trump’s claim that he would allow the police under his command to ‘do whatever the hell they want,’ raising concerns that the civil rights of D.C. residents may be sacrificed in the process." Source: The Leadership Conference
• "Republicans introduced 14 bills or amendments to prohibit noncitizens from voting in D.C. or to repeal, nullify, or prohibit the carrying out of D.C.’s law that permits noncitizens to vote last Congress. Despite being fixated on the subject of D.C. elections, Republicans refuse to make the only election law change D.C. residents have asked Congress to make, which is the right to hold elections for voting members of the House and Senate by passing my D.C. statehood bill." Source: Del. Elanor Holmes Norton (Democrat, D.C.)
Proponents say
• "The bottom line is this bill supports our frontline officers and helps them better protect the public. Police officers should be able to pursue a dangerous vehicle if it is the right thing to do. The ability to be able to do that in D.C. should never have been taken away." Source: Rep. Clay Higgins (Republican, Louisiana)
• "The 2022 Act imposes burdensome restrictions on police pursuit of criminal suspects. This has resulted in less justice for victims of crime in Washington, D.C. and more opportunities for criminals who would otherwise be apprehended to continue harming D.C. and surrounding communities. This bill replaces Subtitle S with policies that allow for vehicular pursuit of a suspect fleeing a motor vehicle if the office or supervisor deems it necessary, the most effective means of apprehension, and without unreasonable risk to bystanders." Source: Rep. James Comer (Republican, Kentucky)