Should Congress cancel the EPA’s approval that lets California set stricter pollution rules for trucks and heavy vehicles?
H.J. Res. 87 is a joint resolution that would invalidate an Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) rule granting California a waiver to enforce its own stricter motor vehicle and engine pollution standards. The EPA rule allowed California to implement measures like the Advanced Clean Trucks rule, Zero Emission Airport Shuttle requirements, and new heavy-duty vehicle emission warranty standards. These regulations aimed to reduce emissions and promote zero-emission technologies. Through H.J. Res. 87, Congress expresses disapproval of this rule under the Congressional Review Act, seeking to prevent California’s standards from taking effect.
Sponsor: Rep. John James (Republican, Michigan, District 10)
View full bill text ➔
How do you feel?
Opponents say
• "The Trump Administration is attempting an end run around the administrative process it is supposed to follow if it intends to revoke the waiver California received for three important programs to cut air pollutants from cars and trucks. The problem for the Trump Administration in using the CRA is that the statute doesn’t apply to waiver decisions. The statute on its face is clear about that and the Governmental Accountability Office has twice made that clear. Nevertheless, just yesterday House Republicans introduced three resolutions to repeal the waivers under the CRA. But their efforts were just dealt a big blow. The Senate Parliamentarian has issued a decision that the CRA does not cover the California waivers. Under normal circumstances, her decision should end the CRA shenanigans. But these are not, of course, normal times. Although the Senate virtually always respects the decisions of the Parliamentarian, recent news reports make clear that Senate Republicans are attempting to bypass her role as the institution’s “referee” in their attempt to extend multi-billion-dollar tax cuts for the rich while claiming the tax cuts will not increase the deficit." Source: Legal Planet - Environmental Law and Climate Policy Insights
• "California, like all other states, has the inherent obligation to protect the health of its citizens. Federal law limiting vehicle pollution has recognized and respected that right for over 50 years, by allowing California to set its own new vehicle emissions standards to address our extraordinary and compelling air pollution problems, and allowing other states to choose those standards as well. California has led the nation in cleaning up cars precisely because our circumstances required more stringent standards to protect public health and clear the air. Now 13 other states and the District of Columbia freely choose to follow our rules. California’s demonstrated progress in leading the nation’s control of vehicle emissions has established a precedent that has benefitted the entire nation when our more stringent rules supplanted national rules over time." Source: California Air Resources Board
Proponents say
• "Michigan is not afraid of the future, but we demand to be a part of it. The Biden Administration left behind comply-or-die Green New Deal mandates that threaten to crush our trucking industry and drive-up costs for hardworking Americans,” said Congressman James. “I know — my family has a trucking company. Republicans are working hard to implement President Trump’s America First agenda, and the first step is repealing the rules and waivers that fueled Biden inflation." Source: Rep. John James (Republican, Michigan, District 10), the sponsor of this resolution
• "Nebraska Attorney General Mike Hilgers is leading the group of GOP attorneys general who filed a petition with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to overturn an Environmental Protection Agency rule limiting truck emissions. Hilgers in a statement said the EPA and California rules ‘will devastate the trucking and logistics industry, raise prices for customers, and impact untold number of jobs across Nebraska and the country. There’s not one trucking charging station in the state of Nebraska,’ Hilgers later told reporters. ‘Trying to take that industry, which was built up over decades with diesel and fossil fuels-based infrastructure, and transforming it to an electric-based infrastructure – it’s probably not feasible.’" Source: AP News Report