Should the President be required to get congressional approval to limit fracking?

This bill has Passed the House of Representatives
Bill Summary

H.R. 1121 would prohibit the President from declaring a temporary or permanent moratorium on hydraulic fracturing, also known as fracking, without approval from Congress. While the Biden administration has instituted additional regulations for fracking and temporarily paused fracking on federally-owned land, there has never been a complete ban on the practice at the federal level. Sponsor: Rep. Jeff Duncan (Republican, South Carolina, District 3)
View full bill text ➔

How do you feel?

You can still save your opinion to your scorecard, but since the vote has already taken place, your opinion won't be sent to your lawmakers.

Opponents say

•      "Fracking Threatens America's Air, Water and Climate. It poisons our water, contaminates our air and emits massive greenhouse gas pollution. Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, involves blasting huge volumes of water mixed with toxic chemicals and sand deep into the earth to fracture rock formations and release oil and natural gas. This extreme form of energy production endangers our health and wildlands. A fracking boom can transform an area almost overnight, creating massive new environmental and social problems. Fracking development is intensifying in Pennsylvania, Texas and North Dakota and moving into new areas, like California and Nevada. Will your state be fracked next? But as fracking spreads across America, communities are fighting back — and the Center for Biological Diversity is working to ban this growing threat." Source: The Center for Biological Diversity 


•      "The Biden-Harris Administration is committed to the highest standards of safety and responsible oil and gas development on public lands. As President Biden has repeatedly stated, oil and gas operations will continue into the future while we transition to a clean energy economy. Neither the President, the Secretary of the Interior, nor the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) have proposed a moratorium on the practice of hydraulically fracturing oil and gas wells. The BLM also notes that States already have discretion over the use of hydraulic fracturing for oil and gas development on State and private lands. Hydraulic fracturing is a common practice for stimulating the flow of oil or gas from a wellbore, and the BLM estimates that the majority of oil and gas wells in production have been hydraulically fractured. The Department of the Interior is concerned that H.R. 1121 would unduly limit the President’s discretion in managing the safe and environmentally protective development of Federal resources from Federal lands. As such, the Department does not support the bill." Source: The Bureau of Land Management 


•      "Since taking office, President Biden has delivered on the most ambitious climate, conservation, and environmental justice agenda in history—taking bold action to reduce climate pollution across every sector of the economy, protecting more than 26 million acres of lands and waters, and restoring the vital role of science in guiding federal decision-making... As a result of the President’s economic and climate leadership, clean energy jobs are on the rise across the country, American manufacturing is booming, companies have announced hundreds of billions of dollars in clean energy investments, and the country is on a path toward cutting climate pollution in half from 2005 levels by 2030 and achieving economy-wide, net zero emissions by no later than 2050." Source: Joe Biden Presidential Administration

Proponents say

•      "No President should have the unilateral power to shut down domestic energy production or fracking… Joe Biden’s War on Energy has put our nation’s energy and national security at risk as he closes down operations that harvest our vast natural resources to convert them to power for everyday life. This legislation stops Joe Biden’s attempt to make America more dependent on our adversaries.Source: Rep. Jeff Duncan (Republican, South Carolina, District 3) 


•      "Since day one in office, President Biden has waged war against American energy production and American energy workers and instead, has turned to, and begged, our adversaries to meet domestic energy demand. House Republicans have worked relentlessly to end this assault on American energy every step of the way. H.R. 1121 is a crucial step in preventing further attacks on U.S. energy production by this administration. We must empower our producers to tap into our rich resources right here at home, where we do it better, and in a more environmentally friendly way, than any other country in the world. America needs an all of the above energy policy, and anything else is capitulating to countries like China, Russia, Venezuela, and Iran. I applaud Representative Duncan for his work on this issue and look forward to passing this bill through the House and into law.Source: Rep. Bruce Westerman (Republican, Arkansas, District 4) 


•      "The Russian invasion of Ukraine and the resulting disruption of the world energy supply has made it

abundantly clear to the world the importance of energy security. Maintaining energy security requires long-term investments and commitments to developing reliable energy sources like oil and gas… Returning to coal has drastically increased the cost of power across the country—significantly damaging their industrialized economy while simultaneously causing emissions to increase. In contrast, the United States is blessed with tremendous sources of domestic energy that, if utilized, can protect us from suffering a similar energy-reliance disaster as experienced in Europe. In addition to renewable energy sources, the United States boasts multiple basins with significant oil and natural gas reserves. As long as we continue to allow Americans to access these resources, we will never face such a dilemma." Source: Tim Tarpley, President of the Energy Workforce & Technology Council