Should Congress vote to send foreign aid to Israel, Taiwan and Ukraine?

This bill has Passed the Senate
Bill Summary

H.R. 815 would send around $95 billion in foreign (mostly military) aid to Israel, Taiwan, and Ukraine. It also would extend the time that these funds will be available - the money dispensed would expire on September 30th of either 2025 or 2027, with expiration dates varying according to the specific use of certain funds. The bill also allocates $98 million in funding toward military-related scientific research, and provides funds for humanitarian assistance in Gaza. Sponsor: Sen. Charles E. Schumer (Democrat, New York)
View full bill text ➔

How do you feel?

You can still save your opinion to your scorecard, but since the vote has already taken place, your opinion won't be sent to your lawmakers.

Opponents say

•    "Open the champagne, pop the cork! The Senate Democrat leader and the Republican leader are on their way to Kyiv! They’ve got 60 billion dollars they’re bringing… taking your money to Kyiv! They didn’t have much time — really no time and no money — to do anything about our border. We’re being invaded, literal invasions coming across our border [...] and all they had time to do in the Senate was get the money, [...] load the planes, get the champagne ready and fly to Kyiv."

Source: Sen. Rand Paul (Republican, Kentucky)


•    "I think we all have to understand that Vladimir Putin will not lose this war. I state it that way as opposed to Ukraine can't win, Vladimir Putin will not lose. Losing to Vladimir Putin is existential to Vladimir Putin. Russia is four times the population. They have a much larger industrial base. So again, I said ‘Russia can produce 4.5 million of those shells a year. We're not even up to a million a year.’ The average age of a Ukrainian soldier right now is 43 years old. And David, I heard you quote the TIME magazine article, there are other quotes from some of Zelensky’s top aides that say even if the U.S. and its allies come through with all the weapons they have pledged, quote, ‘we don't have the men to use them,’ unquote. So the fact of the matter is, if you're worried about the people of Ukraine, you have to understand that probably about 100,000 of their soldiers have been killed, as have been about 100,000 Russian conscripts, I take no joy in that, 40,000 civilians, hundreds of billions of dollars of Ukraine has been destroyed. The only way this war ends is in a settlement, and every day that the war goes on, more Ukrainians, more Russian conscripts die, more civilians die, more of Ukraine gets destroyed. Their lives have to be rebuilt. So again, sending $60 billion as added fuel to the flames of a bloody stalemate makes no sense whatsoever. As evil a war criminal as Putin is, he's not going to lose this war. And our colleagues here just aren't willing to accept that reality. And they're living in a fantasy world, thinking that Ukraine can win this thing. They can't." Source: Sen. Ron Johnson (Republican, Wisconsin)


•      "As I have said many times, Israel has the right to defend itself against Hamas’s terrorism, but it does not have the right to obliterate an entire people… 1.7 million people have been driven from their homes and, unbelievably, some 70 percent of the housing units in Gaza have been damaged or destroyed. This is an unheard-of level of destruction. Nearly 80 percent of the population has been displaced, and they have no idea of where to go, or whether or not they will ever return to their homes. Many of these men, women, and children have been displaced multiple times…Unbelievably, unbelievably, despite all of this, the US Congress is preparing to send another $14 billion to Netanyahu’s right-wing government—$14 billion more. And ten billion of this money is totally unrestricted and will allow Netanyahu to buy more of the bombs he has literally used to flatten Gaza and kill tens of thousands and thousands of children…Does the United States Congress really want to provide more military aid to Netanyahu so that he can annihilate thousands and thousands more men, women, and children?" Source: Sen. Bernie Sanders (Independent, Vermont)

Proponents say

•     "The United States and our allies are facing multiple, complex and, in places, coordinated challenges from adversaries who seek to disrupt democracy and expand authoritarian influence around the globe. These grave threats to U.S. national security require Congress to act with conviction and bipartisanship to confront these challenges. The emergency national security supplemental appropriations agreement does precisely that: it provides billions in vital investments in America’s national security to address growing threats in the Middle East and Red Sea, equips Ukraine to fight off Putin, helps Israel defend itself against forces that wish to wipe a Jewish state off the map while also providing humanitarian assistance to innocent Palestinian civilians in Gaza, answers the call for humanitarian assistance around the world, and bolsters Taiwan and other allies in the Indo-Pacific region against China. This agreement also includes a historic increase in emergency and operational funding for the Nonprofit Security Grant Program to protect at-risk communities and institutions at home. " Source: Sen. Charles E. Schumer (Democrat, New York)


•      "I voted to support the National Security Act because it gives a boost of momentum for the House to take up an imperfect bill and make it better. Leader Schumer’s insistence on poor process, including not allowing amendments, has been disappointing. I submitted multiple changes to strip non-lethal aid and restart approvals of LNG export terminals – one of our greatest national security tools – but they were blocked. The perfect cannot be the enemy of the good. By passing this bill, it moves this critical support forward, but gives the House the opportunity to make it better. In conversations with President Trump and my colleagues, it is clear there could be a path forward if this aid came in the form of loans and targeted on [sic.] lethal military aid rather than humanitarian assistance. This is a moment to unite the country, promote freedom, support our allies, and push back on communist authoritarianism if we can come together and do this right." Source: Rep. Jamie Raskin (Democrat, Maryland, District 8)


•    "I know these conflicts can seem far away.  And it’s natural to ask: Why does this matter to America? So let me share with you why making sure Israel and Ukraine succeed is vital for America’s national security. You know, history has taught us that when terrorists don’t pay a price for their terror, when dictators don’t pay a price for their aggression, they cause more chaos and death and more destruction.  They keep going, and the cost and the threats to America and to the world keep rising…Beyond Europe, we know that our allies and, maybe most importantly, our adversaries and competitors are watching.  They’re watching our response in Ukraine as well. And if we walk away and let Putin erase Ukraine’s independence, would-be aggressors around the world would be emboldened to try the same.  The risk of conflict and chaos could spread in other parts of the world — in the Indo-Pacific, in the Middle East — especially in the Middle East." Source: President Joe Biden (Democrat)