Should Congress denounce President Biden’s immigration policies?

This bill has Passed the House of Representatives
Bill Summary

H. Res. 957, as its name suggests, intends to rebuke President Joe Biden, alongside Vice President Kamala Harris and Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas, for their alleged mishandling of ongoing immigration into the United States. The resolution cites various statistics of immigration rates alongside policies of the Biden administration, claiming that such policies have led to a surge of immigration, bringing with it a rise in crime, drug trafficking, and economic burdens. This resolution does not carry with it any legislative action and is thus largely messaging. Sponsor: Rep. Nathaniel Moren (Republican, Texas, District 1)
View full bill text ➔

How do you feel?

You can still save your opinion to your scorecard, but since the vote has already taken place, your opinion won't be sent to your lawmakers.

Opponents say

•      "President Biden has called on Congress to pass comprehensive immigration reform since his first day in office. As a result of Congress’ failure to enact the reform, the Administration has been using the limited tools it has available to secure the border and build a safe, orderly, and humane immigration system while leading the largest expansion of lawful pathways for immigration in decades. We also urge passage of fully funded emergency appropriations, including the supplemental funding request for border security, as requested by the President this summer. The $4 billion supplemental funding requested for DHS addresses immediate needs of the Department to safely and humanely manage the Southwest Border and to continue implementing our immigration laws through the expansion of lawful pathways and enforcing consequences for those who do not use them. DHS has also allocated more than $770 million to 69 partner organizations in Fiscal Year 2023 to support communities receiving migrants, in both the Southwest Border region and the interior, through the Shelter and Services Program (SSP) and the Emergency Food and Shelter Program – Humanitarian Awards (EFSP-H)." Source: U.S. Department of Homeland Security 


•      "[S]ome Members repeatedly described the number of migrants arriving at the border as an ‘invasion,’ and even went so far as to falsely accuse the Biden-Harris Administration of implementing a plan ‘to deliberately open our border’ for purposes of ‘changing our culture’—mirroring language often used by MAGA extremists who believe that pro-immigration policies are designed to replace white populations with non-white immigrants and other racial minorities. As I explained to you at the hearing, such language borrows from the “Great Replacement” theory, the central dogma of contemporary white supremacy that has been repeatedly invoked by white nationalists to justify violent acts of domestic terrorism, including the mass murders of dozens of Americans at a Tops Supermarket in Buffalo, New York, the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and a Walmart in El Paso, Texas." Source: Rep. Jamie Raskin (Democrat, Maryland, District 8) in a letter cosigned by 20 other Democrats


•      "For decades, immigrants who contribute significantly to our communities and our economy have been relegated to a legal limbo. While the extreme MAGA Republicans make dozens of trips to the border and perform other political stunts, my colleagues and I are once again focusing on immigration action by reintroducing this commonsense registry legislation that is simply an update of the law that was first put in place in 1929. As our predecessors in the 70th Congress understood, providing stability to those who are of good character and who have resided here for a significant period of time is good for America. Updating this historically-bipartisan provision to provide lawful permanent resident status to vetted immigrants who have been a part of our communities for years will make our country stronger." Source: Rep. Zoe Lofgren (Democrat, California, District 18)

Proponents say

•      "President Biden’s open border policies have caused a national public safety crisis, undermined the rule of law, and brought into question the very sovereignty of the United States. By removing effective Trump-era policies like ‘Remain in Mexico’ and replacing them with new ‘Catch and Release’ policies that allow migrants free roam within the United States once here; by broadening the pathway to grant asylum to almost anyone who applies; and by redirecting the efforts of Border Patrol away from law enforcement in favor of processing immigration paperwork, the Biden Administration has sent a loud and clear message to the rest of the world that the southern border is open." Source: Rep. Nathaniel Moran (Republican, Texas, District 1)


•      "The Biden Administration is utterly unprepared to address the… illegal alien surge at our southern border… As a result of the Administration’s open border policies and inadequate planning over the last two years, immigration authorities have neither the resources nor the bandwidth to address yet another border crisis. The Administration—sitting insulated in Washington D.C.—has utterly failed in its constitutional duty to protect the nation. This Administration’s only ‘solution’ to address this anticipated border crisis is to process these migrants en masse into American communities in the interior of the United States. This is criminally dangerous. The Biden Administration can avoid this anticipated surge by enforcing the laws already in place and supporting the policies in the House’s Secure Border Act 2023 that will further strengthen our ability to secure the border and protect our nation’s sovereignty." Source: Rep. Andy Biggs (Republican, Arizona, District 5)


•      "Since the day they took office, President Biden and Secretary Mayorkas have purposefully and maliciously eroded our nation’s border security. They have presided over the worst border crisis we’ve seen in decades and more illegal immigration than any administration in recent history. Now, they aim to sidestep Congress and the law by granting parole to hundreds of thousands of illegal migrants. This is a massive gift to the drug cartels and human traffickers that are killing Americans by the day and wreaking havoc on our country. The American people deserve to know why the Biden Administration has taken this action, and more importantly, what legal justification there is to support it. I’m grateful to Congressman Biggs and all my colleagues who have joined me in this effort to hold President Biden accountable for his disastrous border policies. I look forward to a timely response from Secretary Mayorkas." Source: Sen. J.D. Vance (Republican, Ohio)